I have been having this same issue for the past year, on version 7.3.19.0-0, no update available for Google Play.
This was one of the key features of ESET Mobile for the paid version and it hasn't been working. What are you offering your paid customers for a feature they pay for that doesn't work?
Personally, I do not save any numbers on my SIM, they are all saved on my Google Account, not the phone, so its odd that it is identifying it as such as posts in this thread tend to indicate:
Marcos
Group: Administrators
Posts: 29386
Kudos: 4371
Joined: February 8, 2013
Location: Slovakia
Administrators
Posted June 13
We have found out than on certain devices an update of Android caused the SIM matching feature to malfunction. In such case we recommend temporarily disabling the SIM matching feature and re-enable it after we release ESET Mobile Security v7.4 which will have the feature reworked.